Magento 1 vs 2: Key Differences You Need to Know

Magento 1 vs 2 is a comparison of two versions of the Magento eCommerce platform, where Magento 2 offers significant improvements in performance, flexibility, scalability, and security over Magento 1.

The best Magento 1 vs 2 migration includes a seamless transition, optimized performance, enhanced features, and ongoing support—everything Web Solutions NYC specializes in delivering.

Read this guide to discover why upgrading to Magento 2 is crucial for your business’s success and how to make the transition smoothly with expert help.

Discover the Evolution: Why Magento 1 vs 2 is Crucial for Your eCommerce Success

The shift from Magento 1 to Magento 2 is not just an upgrade—it’s a transformation. If you’re still running your store on Magento 1, you’re limiting your business’s ability to grow, scale, and compete in today’s fast-paced digital market. Magento 2 represents the future of eCommerce, and it’s built to support businesses that want to stay competitive, improve user experience, and take full advantage of advanced features.

At Web Solutions NYC, we’ve worked with both Magento 1 and 2 for over 15 years, helping businesses navigate this evolution. We’ve seen firsthand how sticking to outdated platforms can hold businesses back, and we’ve been there to guide them through the transition to Magento 2, optimizing their processes and increasing their bottom line. From high-performing eCommerce stores to seamless migrations, we’ve been trusted by hundreds of businesses for one reason: results.

Here are the 3 key takeaways from this guide:

1. Magento 2 delivers a superior user experience and vastly improves site performance.
2. Upgrading to Magento 2 is essential to stay competitive and avoid the risks associated with outdated technology.
3. We’ll break down the costs, benefits, and real-world performance improvements you can expect by making the switch.

Let’s dive in and explore how Magento 1 vs 2 compares, and why upgrading is crucial for your business’s success.

The Importance of Upgrading for Modern eCommerce

How Staying on Magento 1 May Limit Growth Opportunities

Staying on Magento 1 means your business is missing out on critical updates, features, and performance improvements. The platform no longer receives official support, making it vulnerable to security breaches and poor scalability. Without regular updates, your site risks becoming slow, unstable, and more difficult to maintain, limiting your ability to compete with businesses on modern platforms. As eCommerce continues to evolve, customers expect fast, seamless experiences—something Magento 1 struggles to provide.

Why Magento 2 Represents the Future of eCommerce Innovation

Magento 2 is built for the modern digital landscape. With faster load times, mobile responsiveness, and better checkout processes, Magento 2 is designed to improve both customer experience and backend efficiency. Features like advanced SEO, integrated PWA capabilities, and modular architecture make it the platform of choice for businesses looking to scale and stay ahead of the competition. Magento 2 also integrates more easily with third-party systems, allowing for greater customization and automation in your eCommerce operations.

The Impact of Legacy Platforms on Business Performance

Hidden Costs of Sticking with an Outdated System

Running a business on Magento 1 comes with hidden costs that can erode profitability over time. Security risks and compliance issues lead to potential data breaches, which could damage your business reputation and result in costly penalties. Additionally, patching outdated software and finding developers who still work with Magento 1 can drive up costs unnecessarily. Instead of investing in modern innovations, businesses on Magento 1 are often forced to spend on band-aid solutions just to keep their systems running.

How Magento 2 Improves Efficiency and Scalability

Switching to Magento 2 allows businesses to run smoother operations with fewer manual processes. Magento 2’s improved scalability ensures that your website can handle spikes in traffic without sacrificing performance. Its more efficient database management and advanced caching mean faster page load times and better server utilization—which directly impacts your business’s ability to grow and handle high traffic volumes. Businesses switching to Magento 2 have reported performance gains of up to 50% in terms of page load times.

A Glimpse into the Future: The End of Support for Magento 1

Critical Deadlines and What They Mean for Businesses

Since June 2020, Magento 1 has reached end of life (EOL) status, meaning there are no more official security patches or updates available. This is a critical deadline that businesses can’t afford to ignore. Without these updates, your site is exposed to a greater risk of hacking attempts, data leaks, and performance issues. Moving to Magento 2 not only ensures continued security updates but also provides access to ongoing improvements and innovations that Magento 1 can no longer offer.
Now that we’ve highlighted the significant risks of staying on Magento 1, let’s explore the core features that make Magento 2 a powerful upgrade for your business.

Performance Comparison: Speed, Scalability, and Security

Magento 2 Performance Boost: Faster Sites, Happier Customers

Let’s face it—nobody likes a slow website. In eCommerce, speed isn’t just about convenience; it’s about keeping your customers happy and driving conversions. Studies show that a mere 1-second delay in page load times can reduce conversions by 7%. That’s why Magento 2 is engineered for speed. With advanced caching techniques, PHP 7 support, and an improved indexing system, Magento 2 is up to 50% faster than Magento 1. Faster load times mean your customers stay engaged, and bounce rates plummet.

Need proof? One of our clients saw a 30% increase in conversions within the first month of migrating to Magento 2, simply because their site became faster and more responsive. Magento 2 takes user experience seriously by ensuring that speed is built into the core of your store.

Scalability: Handling Growth Without Compromise

As your business grows, so do the demands on your eCommerce platform. Magento 1 struggles to keep up with high traffic volumes, often leading to crashes or slowdowns during peak times. With Magento 2, this is a non-issue. It’s designed to handle large-scale operations, effortlessly managing high-traffic sites without compromising performance.

For instance, one of our clients experienced a 200% traffic spike during a major sale event. On Magento 1, their site would have buckled under the pressure. But with Magento 2’s scalability, it handled the influx like a champ. The platform’s improved database handling and optimized query processing allow you to scale smoothly, ensuring you’re ready for Black Friday surges or unexpected viral moments.

Security Overhauls: Magento 2’s Built-in Protection

In today’s world, security is non-negotiable. If your site is vulnerable, your business (and reputation) is at risk. Magento 2 takes security to the next level with regular updates, two-factor authentication (2FA), and stronger encryption algorithms. Unlike Magento 1, which no longer receives official security patches, Magento 2 is consistently updated to ward off vulnerabilities.

Magento 2 also includes a built-in security suite, which makes it easier to protect sensitive customer data and comply with GDPR and PCI DSS regulations. These upgrades make Magento 2 a much more robust platform for businesses handling large amounts of personal and financial data.

One of our clients in the healthcare sector, where security is paramount, transitioned from Magento 1 to Magento 2 and immediately noticed a significant decrease in security concerns, thanks to these built-in protections.

Here’s a quick comparison of Magento 1 vs Magento 2 when it comes to performance, scalability, and security:

Magento 2 clearly outshines Magento 1 in performance, scalability, and security, making it the go-to choice for businesses looking to scale and protect their digital assets.

Next, let’s dive into how Magento 2 opens up a world of customization possibilities to tailor your eCommerce experience!

Migration from Magento 1 to Magento 2: What You Need to Know

When to Migrate: A Timely Decision for Your Business

So, you’re still on Magento 1, and you’re probably wondering, “When is the right time to migrate?” Well, the short answer is: yesterday. But let’s dive into why that is. The longer you stay on Magento 1, the more you’re risking your business in terms of security, performance, and scalability. With official support for Magento 1 long gone, your store is becoming increasingly vulnerable to security breaches, which is a ticking time bomb for any eCommerce business.

But it’s not just about avoiding disaster—it’s about unlocking the future. Migrating early to Magento 2 allows you to immediately take advantage of its superior performance, enhanced features, and better SEO. Plus, doing it now gives you more time to prepare and execute the migration with minimal stress.

How the Migration Process Works: Steps to a Smooth Transition

The migration process might seem intimidating, but with the right tools and guidance, it can be a smooth and manageable journey. First, you’ll need to use Magento’s official Data Migration Tool. This tool helps you transfer all your crucial data—customers, orders, products, and configurations—from Magento 1 to Magento 2 with minimal hassle. It’s like packing up your old store and moving into a new, better-equipped building.

Of course, you’ll want to avoid common pitfalls that can lead to downtime or data loss. At Web Solutions NYC, we recommend doing the migration in stages: starting with data migration, testing thoroughly, and only then migrating your customizations and extensions. We’ve helped dozens of clients with this process, and our secret sauce is planning. For example, we often recommend clients migrate during their off-peak hours to minimize any disruptions.

And remember: test, test, test. Before flipping the switch on your new Magento 2 site, make sure every component is functioning perfectly.

The Cost of Migration: Budgeting for Success

Let’s be real—migrating isn’t free. But look at it as an investment in your future. On average, the cost of migration depends on the size and complexity of your store. The bigger and more customized your Magento 1 site, the more time and resources it will take to move everything to Magento 2.

But here’s the kicker: the ROI you’ll see post-migration makes it well worth it. A smoother, faster site will not only improve user experience, but also lead to higher conversions. And when you factor in the cost of staying on Magento 1—such as potential security breaches or downtime—moving to Magento 2 starts to look like a no-brainer.

At Web Solutions NYC, we’ve seen clients report increases in sales and improved efficiency within the first three months of migrating. Yes, you’ll need to budget for the migration, but with strategic planning, the returns you’ll get from Magento 2 will pay for themselves in no time.

Here’s a quick comparison of key factors to consider when planning your migration from Magento 1 to Magento 2:

The migration to Magento 2 isn’t just an upgrade; it’s an opportunity to take your store to the next level. With the right approach, you can make the switch efficiently and start seeing real results.

Now that you understand the migration process, let’s talk about why Magento 2 is the ultimate solution for future-proofing your eCommerce business!

Magento 1 vs 2: FAQs

Is it worth upgrading from Magento 1 to Magento 2 now?

Absolutely. The benefits of upgrading to Magento 2 are not only worth it—they’re critical to your store’s success. Staying on Magento 1 means you’re operating with outdated technology, limited support, and growing security risks. On the flip side, Magento 2 offers faster performance, better scalability, and the ability to keep up with modern eCommerce trends like mobile-first design and personalized customer experiences. Upgrading isn’t just an investment; it’s a survival strategy for any eCommerce business that wants to remain competitive.

Plus, who wouldn’t want a faster website, smoother checkout process, and more customization options? The benefits are immediate and long-lasting.

What are the risks of staying on Magento 1?

Let’s put it this way: staying on Magento 1 is like driving an old car that hasn’t been serviced in years—it’s only a matter of time before something goes horribly wrong. The biggest risk? Security vulnerabilities. Since Magento 1 is no longer supported, it isn’t receiving any security patches or updates. This leaves your site exposed to hackers and malicious attacks, which can result in data breaches and customer trust loss.

Another risk is limited functionality. As new technologies and eCommerce features emerge, Magento 1 will fall even further behind, making it harder for your business to adapt. The longer you wait, the more costly and complicated it becomes to migrate later. Don’t wait until disaster strikes—upgrade before the risks outweigh the reward.

How long does it take to migrate from Magento 1 to 2?

The time it takes to migrate depends on the size and complexity of your store. A smaller store with fewer customizations can make the transition in as little as three to four months. However, if you’ve got a more complex setup with multiple custom integrations, the process could take closer to six months or longer.

But don’t let that timeline scare you. With proper planning and an experienced team (hey, Web Solutions NYC can help with that!), you can minimize downtime and ensure a smooth transition. The key is to break the migration process into manageable phases—starting with data, then extensions, and finally, custom features. A little patience goes a long way when upgrading to Magento 2.

Can I customize Magento 2 like I did with Magento 1?

Not only can you customize Magento 2 like you did with Magento 1, but you can do it better. Magento 2 was built with a more modular architecture, meaning you can add and customize extensions without having to rewrite core code. This makes the platform more flexible and allows for easier updates without breaking existing functionality.

With thousands of extensions available for Magento 2, you can tailor your store’s features to fit your exact business needs. And if you’re running a highly customized business, the API-driven architecture makes it even easier to integrate with third-party applications or create custom workflows. In short: yes, customization is still a big win with Magento 2, but now it’s smarter and more efficient.

These are just some of the common questions we hear about Magento 1 vs 2, but each store is unique. If you’re thinking about making the leap, it’s important to evaluate your specific needs and reach out to experts like us to guide you through the process.

Your Path to a Superior eCommerce Experience Starts with Magento 2

How Web Solutions NYC Can Help Your Business Thrive

When it comes to seamless migration and unlocking the full potential of Magento 2, you want a partner who has been in the trenches, not just talking the talk. That’s where Web Solutions NYC comes in. We don’t just migrate your store from Magento 1 to Magento 2—we build a strategy around your specific needs to ensure that the process is smooth, efficient, and impactful. No one-size-fits-all solutions here. We take the time to understand your business, your customers, and what you need to thrive in the eCommerce world.

Our tailored approach includes extensive planning, data migration expertise, and a roadmap to minimize downtime. But we don’t stop there. Once you’ve made the jump to Magento 2, our work has just begun. We provide ongoing support to help you maximize your investment. That means optimizing performance, making sure your store runs like a well-oiled machine, and helping you scale as your business grows.

For example, one of our clients was able to reduce their cart abandonment by 25% within the first two months of migrating to Magento 2—all thanks to performance tuning and user experience enhancements we implemented post-migration. That’s the kind of ROI we aim for.

Don’t Wait: Take Action and Secure Your eCommerce Future

Here’s the thing: the longer you wait, the more you risk falling behind in the rapidly evolving world of eCommerce. Magento 2 isn’t just a shiny new toy; it’s a tool that ensures your business remains competitive, secure, and scalable. By transitioning now, you’re setting yourself up for future success. Imagine faster load times, smoother customer journeys, and the ability to adapt to new technologies like AI and PWA.

And here’s the good news: Web Solutions NYC is here to make the entire process painless. Our team of Magento experts has a proven track record of successful migrations, and we know how to sidestep the common pitfalls that other businesses struggle with. We’ll handle the technical stuff, while you focus on growing your business.

Still on the fence? Consider this: every day you stay on Magento 1, you’re losing out on potential sales, performance improvements, and future opportunities. And we’re here to help you make that leap to Magento 2—a platform that’s built for the future. Let us be the partner that ensures your transition is strategic, smooth, and focused on long-term growth.

Ready to future-proof your business with Magento 2? We’re just one call away from getting started on your journey to eCommerce excellence. Let’s make it happen!

Ready to Make the Move? Sign Up for a Free Magento 1 vs 2 Strategy Session and Project Estimate

It’s time to stop wondering and start taking action. If you’re still on Magento 1, you’re not just risking your site’s performance and security—you’re missing out on the power and profitability that Magento 2 can offer. And here’s the best part: we’re here to make the transition easy for you.

At Web Solutions NYC, we understand that every eCommerce business is different. That’s why we’re offering a free strategy session specifically tailored to your needs. Whether you’re curious about the migration process, need help with customization, or want to understand the long-term benefits of upgrading, we’ve got you covered.

What You Get in the Free Strategy Session:

• A custom roadmap for migrating from Magento 1 to Magento 2
• A detailed project estimate that fits your business goals
• Personalized tips and recommendations to optimize your store post-migration

And here’s the kicker—there’s no obligation. This strategy session is all about helping you make the best decision for your business. Our expert team will walk you through the process step-by-step, so you’ll have a clear understanding of the costs, timelines, and benefits before you make any decisions.

Why Wait? Let’s Make Your Store Faster, Smarter, and Ready for the Future!

Click the button below to sign up for your free Magento 1 vs 2 strategy session and project estimate. You’ve already read about the countless benefits of Magento 2—now it’s time to take the next step. Let’s start building the future of your eCommerce business together!

Schedule Your Free Magento 1 vs 2 Strategy Session Now